What was once expected to be a breakthrough season for Jordan Walker is now raising serious concerns within the St. Louis Cardinals organization.
After a series of underwhelming performances, the Cardinals are reportedly reassessing whether the high expectations placed on their young star are justified. Once hailed as one of the brightest prospects in baseball, Walker’s recent struggles have led to growing alarm, with his performance falling far below the expectations set by both the front office and coaching staff.
The latest setback came in a game where Walker continued to falter at the plate, extending his slump to an alarming level. Batting just .196 with a 31.1% strikeout rate, the Cardinals are facing a decision regarding his future with the team. Insiders within the organization have expressed frustration over his inability to replicate the success he showed in the minors, particularly after his high-profile call-up.
“We didn’t bring him up for this,” said one team source, who requested anonymity. “He was supposed to be a key part of our lineup, a player we could rely on. Instead, we’re watching a guy struggle just to make consistent contact. We’re going to have to make some tough decisions soon.”

Despite his potential and past accolades, Walker’s struggles have been compounded by a lack of power, hitting just 3 home runs with 10 RBIs in over 100 at-bats. His inability to make solid contact and his tendency to swing and miss have made it increasingly difficult for the team to justify his place in the starting lineup.
Following the recent slump, Manager Oliver Marmol has made the decision to temporarily move Walker down in the lineup, stating, “He needs to reset. We believe in Jordan’s potential, but right now, he’s not where we need him to be. Our priority is winning, and we feel this is the best move for the team at this moment.”
This change has sparked discussions within the organization about whether a more permanent adjustment is necessary. With the Cardinals locked in a tight race for the postseason, the team cannot afford to have a young player who is underperforming in such a critical role. Sources close to the situation suggest that the Cardinals are considering sending Walker down to the minors to regain his confidence or even explore trade options if his struggles persist.
For now, Walker will have time to work on his mechanics away from the pressure of regular starting duties. But the clock is ticking, and with each game, the team grows more impatient.
“We’ve got to make sure he gets back to the player we know he can be,” said Marmol. “If he does that, he’ll be back in the lineup. But right now, we need results, and we need them fast.”
As the Cardinals look to secure a playoff spot, the question remains: Can Jordan Walker turn things around, or will this season be remembered as a missed opportunity for both him and the team?