Yankees Make Quiet But Telling Bullpen Move in 2025
The New York Yankees are surging this season, and while the wins pile up, some tough internal decisions are being made quietly.
On Monday, the team discreetly released veteran reliever Tyler Matzek, who chose to become a free agent rather than accept a demotion to the minors.
Though it wasn’t a headline-grabbing move, it highlighted an important aspect of the Yankees’ bullpen philosophy.
Why Matzek’s Release Matters
At 34, Matzek wasn’t brought in to be a key bullpen piece. He was more of a depth option — a low-risk acquisition with potential upside.
Over 6.1 innings this year, he struggled with control and effectiveness, posting a 4.26 ERA and failing to miss many bats.
Hitters weren’t fooled, and he gave up too much solid contact. With the Yankees aiming to construct a dominant bullpen, there was no room for inconsistent performance.
Rather than report to Triple-A Scranton/Wilkes-Barre, Matzek opted for free agency — a common move for a veteran but one that underscores the team’s confidence in their current relievers.
The Numbers Game in the Bullpen
When Jonathan Loaisiga returned from injury, many expected Yerry De Los Santos to be cut. Instead, De Los Santos remained, and Matzek was let go.
That decision speaks volumes. De Los Santos has been steady and offers more long-term promise, fitting better into a bullpen with World Series goals.
With Loaisiga back and Devin Williams pitching well alongside other contributors, there’s no space for underperformance.
Depth and Competition Tighten the Roster
The Yankees also brought back Scott Effross (currently in Triple-A) and are expecting more help from the minors and potentially via trades.
Loaisiga, in his season debut, showed elite velocity and poise — a sign he’s ready to contribute at a high level again.
With so much bullpen depth and high expectations, the Yankees can’t afford to waste innings.
A Reflection of Standards, Not Failure
Matzek’s departure isn’t a failure — it’s a reflection of how high the bar is in New York. With October in sight, only the most effective arms will stay in the mix.
Matzek may still find a role elsewhere, especially given the constant demand for left-handed relievers.
But in the Bronx, the message is clear: with a championship in sight, only the best make the cut.
