In a move that’s both nostalgic and strategic, the New York Yankees have brought Billy McKinney back to the Bronx, signing the outfielder to a multi-year deal following his release from the New York Mets over the weekend.
McKinney, 30, was let go by the Mets on May 18 after spending the first part of the 2025 season with Triple-A Syracuse. Just days later, the Yankees have stepped in—not just to provide depth, but to make a clear statement: they see value, experience, and upside in the veteran outfielder.
A Familiar Face Returns
This marks McKinney’s third stint with the Yankees organization. Originally part of the 2016 trade that sent Aroldis Chapman to the Cubs, McKinney made his MLB debut with the Yankees in 2018. After bouncing around the league with stops in Toronto, Milwaukee, Los Angeles, Oakland, and most recently, Queens, the outfielder now finds himself back where it all began.
In 2023, McKinney rejoined the Yankees and had a solid showing, slashing .226/.320/.406 with 4 home runs in 48 games. His ability to step into a game at a moment’s notice—often playing all three outfield spots—made him a reliable option off the bench.
Long-Term Commitment, Strategic Role
According to team sources, the Yankees have signed McKinney to a two-year contract with a club option for a third, signaling more than just a depth move. With Giancarlo Stanton’s ongoing injury concerns and Aaron Judge’s workload being closely managed, McKinney is expected to take on a vital rotational role in the outfield.
/cdn.vox-cdn.com/uploads/chorus_image/image/69439351/1320383498.0.jpg)
Manager Aaron Boone commented on the signing Tuesday afternoon ahead of the Yankees’ series opener against the Texas Rangers:
“Billy knows New York. He knows this clubhouse. He brings grit, flexibility, and a left-handed bat we value. He’s not just a fill-in — he’s part of the plan moving forward.”
McKinney is expected to report to the Yankees’ active roster within the next few days and could see game action as soon as Thursday, especially with the team facing a stretch of 13 games in 14 days.
A Full-Circle Moment
For McKinney, this return to the Bronx is more than a business transaction — it’s a second chance at home.
“I’ve been through a lot of uniforms,” McKinney said in a statement Tuesday. “But the pinstripes always felt different. I’m thankful to be back, and I’m ready to contribute however I can.”
With over 300 major league games under his belt and a reputation as a hard-nosed competitor, McKinney brings the type of versatility and clubhouse familiarity the Yankees have increasingly leaned on in recent years.
Looking Ahead
While the Yankees continue to jockey for position atop the AL East, the addition of McKinney gives the team another steady hand—one who knows the pressure of playing in the Bronx and thrives in it.
Don’t be surprised if Billy McKinney’s comeback turns into one of the more underrated storylines of the 2025 season.
