Reds Look to Reinforce Bullpen with Former Brewers Ace Devin Williams
After a strong 2025 from Emilio Pagan, who notched a 2.88 ERA and 32 saves, the Cincinnati Reds face a big offseason question: how to replace key bullpen arms now in free agency.
Devin Williams: The Reliever Who Made the Reds Look Silly
One name the Reds are reportedly eyeing is Devin Williams, who terrorized Cincinnati hitters for years while with the Milwaukee Brewers. Williams debuted in 2019, posting a 3.95 ERA in 13 games, and by 2020, he had become virtually unhittable, allowing just one run in 27 innings. Over the next four seasons, he maintained elite numbers, finishing 2024 with a 1.83 career ERA.
Against the Reds specifically, Williams was nearly untouchable. From 2019–2024, Cincinnati managed a paltry .098/.189/.143 line against him, with 64 strikeouts in 127 plate appearances, and just five earned runs scored in 34 games (1.32 ERA).
A Rough Stretch in New York – Can Williams Bounce Back?
Williams was traded to the Yankees 13 months ago, and 2025 was more challenging. His ERA rose to 4.79 over a career-high 62 innings in 67 appearances. While his strikeout rate dipped, he still kept hitters to a .196 average and posted his lowest walk rate since 2020 — signs he could rebound in the right environment.
How Much Will the Reds Have to Pay for Elite Relief?
Salary projections for Williams vary widely. The Athletic predicts a one-year deal worth $18 million, MLB Trade Rumors suggests four years at $68 million, and ESPN’s Jeff Passan sees three years for $45 million. Any of these deals would be a major financial commitment for Cincinnati, potentially consuming half or more of their free-agent budget for 2026.
Big Decisions Ahead: Will Williams Be a Red?
If the Reds want to fortify their bullpen with a proven, elite arm, Williams could be the answer — but the price tag might force some tough choices. One thing’s for sure: this offseason could define Cincinnati’s pitching for years to come.
