The Los Angeles Dodgers moved on from former third-round pick Dustin May during the 2025 season after he returned from a year in which he did not pitch. Following an inconsistent first half, the organization ultimately determined it was best to trade him for prospect capital.
- “The Red Sox were aggressive in the starting pitching market ahead of the Trade Deadline, and negotiations went down to the final moments,” MLB.com’s Ian Browne wrote. “Chief baseball officer Craig Breslow ultimately completed a last-minute deal, acquiring right-hander Dustin May from the Dodgers in exchange for outfield prospects James Tibbs III and Zach Ehrhard.”
Although he was dealt midseason, May remained part of the Dodgers’ 2025 championship run after contributing earlier in the year, qualifying him to receive a World Series ring—his third with the franchise.
“They were all my guys. It was definitely fun to watch,” May said. “I played with them for four and a half months or however long it was, so I know I helped and contributed to getting them there.”
On Wednesday, the St. Louis Cardinals officially finalized May’s contract, signaling a fresh start after a difficult 2025 campaign.
“Dustin May’s deal with the Cardinals is official,” ESPN’s Jeff Passan reported. “He will earn $12.5 million this season, with a $20 million mutual option for 2027.”
May now enters a pivotal stretch in his career, with the next year or two critical in proving he can still deliver meaningful value at the major league level. However, another significant injury could severely limit future opportunities with contending teams.
The Cardinals, meanwhile, appear to be at the early stages of a rebuild. With Nolan Arenado, Brendan Donovan, and Willson Contreras all frequently mentioned in trade rumors, substantial roster changes may be on the horizon. For May, the mission is straightforward: capitalize on this opportunity and reestablish his footing in the majors.
